DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY BOARD MINUTES

September 20, 2007

Development Advisory Board (DAB)

 

 

DAB Members Present

Ben Barcon

Rus Brock

Gary Corcoran

Bernie Deutsch

Herb Hacker

John B. Hart

Barbara Koffron

 

Larry Litchfield

John Mackay

Jason Morris

Ben Patton

Alex Reynoso

Paul Scott

DAB Members Absent

Haley Balzano

Peter Hemingway

Ken Roth

Darrell Wilson

Ex-Officio’s Present

Mike Hamblin, LAW

Chaun Hill, Streets

Nazario Prieto, WSD

Sam McAllen, NSD

Larry Tom, Planning Dept.

 

Tom Wandrie, DSD

Ex-Officio’s Absent

 

City of Phoenix Staff

Lionel D. Lyons, Director, DSD

Derek D. Horn, DSD

Deb Richardson, DSD

Pam Hibbs, DSD

Wendy Simons, DSD

 

 

Cindy Stotler, DSD

Frank Dancil, DSD

Jennifer Cleis, DSD

Others in Attendance

Analice Baker, ASU Student

Varnell Smith, ASU Student

Rick Doell, Citizen

 

 

1.                   Call to order:

Paul Scott, DAB Chairperson, convened the meeting at 3:05 p.m.

 

2.                   Approval of July 19, 2007, minutes.

 

a Motion was made by Ben Patton and seconded by Gary Corcoran,, to approve the July 19, 2007, meeting minutes.   MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.

 

3.                   Call to the Public (No Board Discussion)

No response from the public

 

4.                               Introduction of the new DAB members:

Paul Scott introduced and welcomed Jason Morris and John Mackay to the Development Advisory Board as new members.  Jason Morris, a land use attorney, will represent the residents of Phoenix for the board.  He brings to the board 15 years of experience on project developments within the City of Phoenix and other municipalities within the state of Arizona.   John Mackay, a Service Manager for Commonwealth Electric Company of the Mid West, will bring to the board a background of 35 years in the industrial and commercial industry and will represent contractors for the board.  

 

5.                               Update on Department Fiscal Position:

Management Services Administrator, Cindy Stotler gave a brief update on the fiscal position of the Development Services Department.  Ms. Stotler informed the board that the current state of the economy has negatively affected the department revenue this fiscal year, which started in July of 2007.  She informed the board that since her last update (July of 2007) which she reported on the previous fiscal year, which ended in June of 2007, the department was looking at a revenue shortage. 

DSD Director, Lionel D. Lyons addressed the board with his comments and told the board that he has informed the Mayor’s office, City Council, the department’s bargaining groups and labor union of the situation.  Further, he stressed to the board that the department has an obligation to inform the employees of the situation of which, it plans to do so aggressively next week.  He affirmed the board that though DSD is short on details right now it is taking a proactive approach in addressing the issues at hand and would do its best to keep everyone well informed.

 

Paul Scott suggested that the department evaluate the rainy day fund and contract work and its impact on the department for the future and provide the information at subcommittee meetings and the next DAB meeting.

 

6.                               Boards Commissions and Open Meeting Law requirements:

Open Meeting Law Coordinator, Becky Zaudtke gave a brief overview of the Open Meeting Law requirements and expectations of the board in maintaining boards and commissions standards.  Topic highlights included proper posting of agendas, merits of agenda items, results and minutes, obtaining a quorum to hold meeting, known conflict of interest before or during a meeting and inappropriate communication through other means i.e. phone, fax and email, besides what is acceptable in a boardroom setting.  Assistant City Attorney Michael Hamblin briefed the board on appropriate and inappropriate use of executive sessions during a board meeting and the legal ramifications if there is a conflict of interest.

 

7.                               Subcommittee Reports:

 

Process and Procedures

Ben Barcon:  The subcommittee met on Friday, September 7, 2007 and discussed the following items:

§         New Civil plan review process

§         Landscape technical registration

§         A policy to limit the number of plan reviews on construction plans

 

Fiscal and Performance

Russ Brock:  Nothing to report

 

Project Simple:

Bernie Deutsch informed the board that Project Simple has a round table discussion scheduled for September 25, 2007, in which the development industry and staff members will provide an educational workshop for DSD staff and interested parties.

 

Electronic Plan Review

Paul Scott:  Nothing to report.

 

Residential Fire Sprinklers:

Ken Roth:  Nothing to report.

 

Technical:

Herb Hacker:  Nothing to report.

 

Water:

Rus Brock:  informed the board that the subcommittee meeting met and discussed the following items:

§         A light rail addendum to the Design Standards Manual.

§         A new procedure for the review of private lift stations

§         Proposed procedures on water meter issuance to mixed use developments

 

 

 

8.                   Update, information and discussion regarding following possible building code amendments:  

Discussion began with a brief overview of the code amendment process given by Derek D. Horn, Assistant Director of DSD.  The following sub-items were discussed:

8.1       Waterless Urinals

8.2       Areas of refuge in sprinklered buildings

8.3       Drinking fountains at the shell building phase

8.4       Urinal substitution

 

After discussion on possible code amendments of the aforementioned sub-items, the Board decided that the Department will further the study of possible amendment issues for the following sub-items and bring them back to the board at a later date for approval:

 

8.1 Waterless Urinals         8.2 Areas of refuge in sprinklered buildings

8.4 Urinal substitution for water closets

 

A Motion was made by board member, Herb Hacker and seconded by John Hart to approve a department study of sub-item 8.1 Motion Carried unanimously

 

Public Comments:

During a discussion regarding sub-item 8.2, public comments from citizen, Rick Doell suggested that the board review the 2007 supplements. 

 

A Motion was made by board member, Ben Patton and seconded by Larry Litchfield to approve a department study of sub-item 8.2  Motion Carried by a vote of 10/3

 

A Motion was made by board member, Herb Hacker and seconded by John Hart to approve a department study of sub-item 8.4  Motion Carried unanimously

 

After discussion on possible code amendments to the following sub-items, the subcommittee decided the following sub-items are withdrawn from possible studies:

 

8.3  Drinking fountains at the shell building phase       8.5 Others

               

9.                   Second Call to Public:

Chair recognized private citizen Rick Doell:

                Mr. Doell gave observations regarding the coordination of the Development Advisory Board and its meetings and made suggestions to the board  as to how to better inform the public of what the DAB does for the community.  Mr. Doell’s suggestions were duly noted by the board’s Chair and its members.

 

10.                Discussion Regarding Future DAB Agenda Items:

·         Enforcement of truncated domes with detectable warnings

·         Information from staff regarding compliance with the Liz Carabine Ordinance

·         Adding verbiage to future agendas indicating that a quorum may exist during a teleconference

·         Adding verbiage to future agendas indicating that a possible executive session may take place

 

11.                Adjournment:

 

MOTION was made by Bernie Deutsch, seconded by Alex Reynoso, to adjourn the

September 20, 2007 meeting.   MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY

               

Meeting adjourned at 5:04 p.m.

Minutes Prepared by: Deb Richardson, Secretary III